By Jeff Altman, Big Game Hunter
EP 3142 Most job seekers view LinkedIn and Indeed as interchangeable versions of the same thing. This is exactly why their applications are ignored. One is a high-speed search engine; the other is a high-value professional network. If you’re tired of shouting at empty “Easy Apply” buttons, then you need to understand the basic DNA of these platforms. In this no-nonsense guide, we detail when to use each tactic to double your interview rates and stop wasting time on the wrong tactics. “
This is episode 3142 of No Bullshit Job Advice Radio.
Okay, let’s get started. Today we’re going to tackle a big question: LinkedIn vs. Indeed.
But listen, this isn’t going to be some boring feature list. No, we’re digging for real strategy guides. The goal here is to help you figure out which platform to use, when to use it, and most importantly, why to use it so you can stop just wasting your efforts and actually start seeing some results.
Here’s the game plan for today. First, we’ll look at the core ideas of each platform. You know, what makes them tick? Then we’ll get into the hard data.
What do these numbers actually say? From that point on, we’ll have a specific strategy for all laptop professionals. We’ll also cover the real highlights of Indeed. Finally, we’ll wrap it all up with a simple, no-nonsense strategy that you can put into action, like today.
Well, let’s make one thing clear right from the start. LinkedIn and Indeed are not the same thing. You can’t just trade one for the other.
If you want to use them effectively, you absolutely must understand their purpose. I mean, they were born from completely different ideas. They have completely different DNA.
So what is the fundamental difference? Well, think of it this way. LinkedIn started out as a professional network, right? It’s all about building your reputation and making connections. The Working Committee was only fixed later.
This is key because it applies to people who are actively searching as well as the passive candidates that recruiters like to look for. But in fact, it gave birth to a job search engine pure and simple. It’s built for speed, fast searches, and fast applications.
It is suitable for people who are actively looking for a job at the moment. Okay, so we have these two completely different methods. But what does this actually mean for job hunting in the real world? Let’s cut out all the noise and just look at the cold data.
What do these numbers tell us about where you should really be spending your time and energy? This chart is the core trade-off. That’s all. Through Indeed, you can get a lot of recruitment information.
You can send bulk applications in extremely large quantities. But your interview rate will be lower. Now let’s look at LinkedIn.
It completely flips the script. Yes, you may send out fewer applications, but your chances of actually getting an interview go up significantly. It’s truly a classic showdown of quantity versus quality.
I mean, let’s understand this first. You’re twice as likely to get an interview. If you remember one number today, remember this.
It proves that sending out 100 applications on Indeed may make you feel productive, but sending out just 20 truly targeted, well-thought-out applications on LinkedIn can get you further. This is the definition of working smarter, not harder. That’s the reason behind it all.
It depends on how employers view these platforms. They view Indeed as a way to cast a net, you know, to fill the top of their recruiting pipeline with a large pool of candidates. But when it comes to those professional roles, your specific experience and background are absolutely critical, and they’ll choose LinkedIn.
They hope to find more targeted, higher-quality candidates there. They just fish for different fish in different ponds. Okay, with all the data in our back pocket, let’s get started with tactics.
If you’re what we call a laptop professional, you know, working in the corporate or tech world, maybe a remote-friendly job, your strategy has to be laser-focused. For you, LinkedIn is definitely your main stage. Here are three important reasons.
First, your profile provides more context than a boring resume. Recruiters actually use it to see if you would be a good fit. Secondly, the entire platform is built for the Internet.
This is your secret weapon to get into the hidden job market and get a warm introduction. Third, and this is an important question, a great profile is always working for you behind the scenes, attracting recruiters and creating opportunities, even if you’re not actively looking for them. Yes, you really can’t think of LinkedIn as just a job site anymore.
For professionals, it means much more than that. This is your life resume. This is your personal PR engine.
This is your direct line of contact with the person making the hiring decision. Here you can build your reputation, showcase your knowledge, and make connections that can land you your next great role. Sometimes even before anyone else knows the job exists.
But hang in there. This doesn’t mean we should throw Indeed in the trash. not at all.
You just need to know what its superpower is. Indeed’s power is pure, unfiltered volume, velocity and massive reach. For certain types of work, trust me, it’s the undisputed king.
Make your AI editing resume stand out
So where does its true dominance lie? Massive hiring, that’s what. Think about it. For example, a company needs to hire 50 warehouse workers or 20 customer service representatives.
They need them soon. They will go directly to Indeed. every time.
Now it remains an amazing market research tool for laptop professionals. You can perform a quick search directly and see job titles and salary ranges instantly. Plus, it’s great for finding these roles at companies that aren’t very active on LinkedIn.
Okay, we’ve got the theory there. We looked at the data. We’ve discussed the script.
Now it’s time to take them all home. Let’s build a simple, no-nonsense strategy that you can start using as soon as this is all over. This is how you make both platforms work for you.
This table puts almost everything side by side. If you’re a laptop pro, LinkedIn is your home. This is your main stage for branding, networking, and sending out those really high-quality apps.
You use Indeed more as a backup, supplementary tool. Now for everyone else, if you’re an hourly employee, blue collar, or any type of high volume role, you just flip it. Your main engine indeed.
This is your first choice. LinkedIn, on the other hand, is more like a long-term investment and a place to store your professional resume for the future. That’s what it boils down to.
LinkedIn’s strength is quality, Indeed’s strength is quantity. Here are specific step-by-step instructions. Step one, for laptop pros, your week should revolve around LinkedIn.
I’m talking about updating your profile, connecting with people, actually engaging with content. Then, you might log into Indeed once a week to scan the market. Step two, for everyone who works hourly or in operations, you need to take a strong leadership role on Indeed.
Be there every day. This is where the jobs are. Just set up a basic LinkedIn profile.
Think of it as just in case when you’re ready to move up to a supervisor or other company position in the future. This brings me to the most important piece of no-nonsense advice I can give you. This applies no matter which platform you use.
You have to stop relying on that simple app button as your primary strategy. This is a psychological trap. I get it.
It feels good to see an increase in the number of applications you send, but it almost never leads to actual offers because it’s a low-effort move, and recruiters know it. Remember, your goal is not to apply for the most jobs. It’s all about finding the right job.
So I’ll leave it to you to think about this. I want you to take a really honest look at how you spend your job search time. Do you just mindlessly click buttons and hope for the best? Or do you strategically and thoughtfully build a case for the career you really want? Because your strategy really should match your ambitions.
There’s also lots of information to help you at jobsearch.community. Become an insider and get all my content plus guidance from big game hunter Jeff Altman, or you can purchase individual products and services. He can help.
The executive resume game is different
About Big Game Hunter Jeff Altman
People hire big game hunter Jeff Altman to provide no-nonsense career advice around the world because he’s done so much in people’s careers Easier. These matters may involve job hunting, Recruit more effectively, manage and lead better, career transition, and advice on solving workplace problems.
He is the host of “No BS Job Search Advice Radio,” the #1 job search podcast on iTunes with over 3,100 episodes.
Recently Featured YouTube Job Search Videos
You’ll find important information to help you with your job search on my new website, JobSearch.Community In addition to video courses, books, and guides, I answer members’ questions about their job search every day. Leave your job search questions and I will respond every day. Becoming an Insider+ member gives you everything you get as an Insider+ member, plus you can connect with me via Zoom call to get your questions answered. Become an Insider Premium member and we offer individual and group coaching.
Stop bombing your interviews
Also, please subscribe to JobSearchTV.com on YouTube and No BS Job Advice Radiothe #1 job search podcast with over 3,100 episodes in over 12 years. On Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Google Play, Amazon Music, and almost anywhere you listen or watch podcasts.
You can also get your #jobsearchquestions answered on Tuesday at noon ET. Search for career coaching office hours on LinkedIn and mark that you are attending. If you miss the live broadcast, you can access the recording.
Schedule a discovery call on my website, www.TheBigGameHunter.us Talk to me about one-on-one or group coaching
LinkedIn:
Resume and LinkedIn profile critiques www.TheBigGameHunter.us/critiques
How to Create and Market Your Partial Executive Playbook
We allow this and other articles to be used on your site as long as they include a backlink www.TheBigGameHunter.us and states that it is provided by Jeff Altman of The Big Game Hunter as the author or creator. Does not acknowledge his work or provide backlinks www.TheBigGameHunter.us Subjects you to a $1,000 fine, which you voluntarily agree to pay.
